Another Ryder Cup has finished and once again it is the European team who will be taking the trophy home for another two years.
Paul McGinley's men sealed a 16.5-11.5 triumph at Gleneagles to secure their third win in a row and eighth win in the last ten outings.
So what were the main factors behind another European triumph?
1. Paul McGinley's performance as captain
The hero of the 2002 Ryder Cup as a player when he holed the winning putt barely put a foot wrong as captain 12 years later. Having been backed by the vast majority of players including Rory McIlroy, Ian Poulter and Graeme McDowell, he didn't let them down and created a wonderful spirit amongst the Europe dressing room.
His attention to detail was second to none and when he had to make big decisions on pairings, he got most of them spot on. Justin Rose and Henrik Stenson was a decision that bore Europe three points. Foursome partnerships between experienced players like Graeme McDowell and Lee Westwood alongside rookies Victor Dubuisson and Jamie Donaldson respectively bore four points in total and were key to victory.
And on the final day, his decision to send out Graeme McDowell first in the singles paid dividends when G-Mac fought from three down to beat Jordan Spieth 2+1. G-Mac is someone who would kill his own granny, so to speak for a singles win and he was exactly the right choice to lead the Europeans out to make sure momentum remained with the home side.
2. The team spirit.
As has been said so many times over the last decade or so, the Ryder Cup always seems to mean more to the European team no matter the team line-up and that was the case once again at Gleneagles. This time around there was nine different nationalities in the European team but they all came together to play for a continent.
Meanwhile, certain Americans looked like they would have rather been anywhere else bar the centenary course at Gleneagles. Bubba Watson barely cracked a smile all weekend. Jimmy Walker looked like he'd have preferred to be on holiday. For all his antics particularly on the Sunday, Patrick Reed at least showed some passion as did fellow rookie Jordan Spieth.
Ian Poulter's passion at Medinah inspired the rest of his European team. Perhaps if Reed had some help in that regard, it would have been a lot closer.
It is truly incredible that every two years 12 men come together to give their all for a continent, yet only twice in the last 15 years have 12 American golfers looked like caring for the Ryder Cup.
3. The foursome results
Europe won the two foursome sessions by a combined 7-1. USA didn't even win a match in those afternoon sessions on the Friday and Saturday relying on two halves to make up that score. That is a truly stunning result and once again shows how the foursome pairings for Europe gelled together and how the Americans simply couldn't get chemistry going with each other bar two rookies in the form of Spieth and Reed.
America more than held their own throughout the rest of the Ryder Cup and indeed won both fourball sessions and put up a great fight in the singles today for long spells. But you can't lose one format 7-1 and expect to win the Ryder Cup.
4. Bad decisions by Tom Watson
As good as Paul McGinley performed as European captain, criticism has to come the way of American captain Tom Watson. Watson was picked because he was the last American captain to win the trophy on European soil, back in 1993 at the Belfry. And there aren't many more respected figures in the world of golf than Watson.
However, for all his experience he got some decisions badly wrong this weekend. The decision to bench Jordan Spieth and Patrick Reed on the Friday afternoon was astounding. The pair had performed brilliantly in the morning to defeat Poulter and Stephen Gallacher 5+4 and were raring to go. The fact that they were benched would have given the European team a big confidence boost.
Another poor decision by Watson was to bench Phil Mickelson and Keegan Bradley for the entire day yesterday. Although they had been beaten 3+2 by McDowell and Dubuisson on Friday afternoon, the pair had proved a tremendous pair at Medinah and surely deserved a chance to put things right. Furthermore, Mickelson was the senior figure in the US team and the seeming lack of trust by Watson in him was strange and it is no surprise to hear that "Lefty" has already criticised Watson's captaincy formula.
5. The differences in choice of vice-captains
Whilst there's certainly a case for arguing that McGinley's appointment of five vice captains was excessive, he certainly made wiser appointments to the team room than Watson.
By hiring Jose Maria Olazabal and Sam Torrance, he had hired two successful European captains, including the man who turned it around at Medinah two years ago. And in Torrance he had someone who knew the course inside out. Factor in the cool and charismatic personality of Miguel Angel Jimenez, and the knowledge of Des Smyth and Padraig Harrington, then McGinley had a winning formula.
Contrast that with Tom Watson. He piled on the experience to his side by picking 72 year old Ray Floyd and 64 year old Andy North. In hindsight this was a mistake. Whilst experience can be an advantage in any sport, in the Ryder Cup it is better to pick vice-captains who still have links with the players. In fairness, Watson did try to do that by selecting Steve Stricker as his third vice-captain. But where were they during the weekend? You barely saw them on Sky's coverage.
Why didn't Watson pick Paul Azinger, the successful Ryder Cup captain from 2008 or even a Justin Leonard or David Toms figure. Another area where McGinley got one over on Watson.
In two years time at Hazeltine, Europe will be strong favourites to win a fourth successive Ryder Cup, something they have never achieved before. There will be strong competition for places considering players like Luke Donald, Francesco Molinari and Nicolas Colsaerts missed out this time to name a few.
For America, they have two years to find a team spirit to stop this tournament developing into one that was as one sided in the pre European days.
No comments:
Post a Comment